Carriers I compare
These are the insurance companies our agency is appointed with. I only quote companies I can actually place you with, and I show them side by side with the same coverage.
Progressive
Drivers who want to compare a usage-based discount and a wide range of add-ons.
How Progressive prices Florida drivers →GEICO
Drivers with clean records who manage everything in an app.
How GEICO prices Florida drivers →Travelers
Homeowners who want to bundle and households with several cars.
How Travelers prices Florida drivers →Kemper
Drivers with a ticket, crash, lapse or a non-standard history.
How Kemper prices Florida drivers →Bristol West
Drivers who need an SR-22, have a lapse, or have a ticket or crash on their record.
How Bristol West prices Florida drivers →National General
Drivers who want flexible payment plans, and many non-standard situations.
How National General prices Florida drivers →United Auto
Florida drivers looking for a lower-cost policy, including the state minimum.
How United Auto prices Florida drivers →Standard and non-standard, in plain words
Standard carriers
Progressive, GEICO and Travelers tend to give their best prices to drivers with clean records, continuous insurance and, for Travelers, a home to bundle.
Non-standard carriers
Bristol West, Kemper, National General and United are built for drivers with a ticket, a crash, a lapse, a new or foreign license, or a filing like an SR-22. Their coverage is real insurance; they just price these drivers better.
How to check any insurance company
- License Every company and agency selling in Florida must be licensed. Check on the Florida DFS licensee search.
- Complaints The NAIC publishes complaint data by company, compared with the company’s size: NAIC Consumer Insurance Search.
- Financial strength Independent rating agencies like AM Best rate whether an insurer can pay claims. Ratings change, so check the current one.
- Your own policy The declarations page shows what you actually bought. David reads it with you, line by line.
Carrier names are trademarks of their owners. Their appearance here doesn’t mean the carrier endorses iSellPolicies.