Save money
Florida car insurance rate cuts in 2026: what they mean for your bill
Short answer
Florida's five largest auto insurance groups show an average 12.6% indicated rate decrease for 2026, and dozens of companies have filed cuts. But a rate filing isn't your premium: your renewal also reflects your car, your drivers, your ZIP code and your record. If your renewal didn't go down, comparing carriers is the fastest way to find out whether it should have.
What the state reports
- The big five: as of fall 2026, the five largest auto groups, about 81% of Florida's market, show an average indicated rate change of -12.6% for 2026, according to the Office of Insurance Regulation (OIR).
- More companies cutting: in January 2026, OIR reported that 42 companies had filed decreases over the past year. That included Progressive at -8%, along with more than $1 billion in refunds.
- GEICO: more than 700,000 Florida customers got rate relief in April 2026, according to the state's announcement.
- Losses are down: Florida's 2025 personal auto liability loss ratio was 52.5%, the lowest in the country and the lowest for Florida in 15 years, per OIR.
- Refunds: in November 2026, OIR announced more than $46 million in excess-profit refunds from one auto insurer under Florida's excess-profits law, and said it expects more.
Why rates are coming down
Florida regulators point to the 2023 legal reforms (HB 837). Negligence lawsuits now generally have to be filed within two years, a person more than 50% at fault for their own injuries can't recover, and attorney fee rules changed. Fewer and smaller lawsuits mean lower losses, and insurers have filed lower rates as a result.
Why your renewal may not go down
- A filing is an average. Some customers get bigger cuts, some get smaller ones, and some still go up.
- Your own changes count more. A new car, a new driver, a ticket, a claim, a move to a different ZIP or a lost discount can outweigh the decrease.
- Repairs cost more. Newer cars with sensors and cameras cost more to fix, which keeps collision and comprehensive high.
- Timing. A decrease applies at your next renewal after it takes effect, not the day it's announced.
How to get the decrease
- Compare this year's declarations page with last year's, line by line: same cars, same drivers, same limits?
- Ask your insurer whether the filed decrease was applied to your renewal.
- Compare carriers on the same limits. David quotes the carriers our agency writes with side by side. Upload your declarations page and he sees exactly what you have.
- Don't cut coverage to save. Bodily injury and uninsured motorist protect you the most in a state where so many drivers carry the minimum. See how to lower your car insurance.
Did Florida get rid of PIP?
No. Bills to repeal no-fault and PIP died in committee in both 2025 and 2026 (in 2026, SB 522 and HB 769 died on March 13). PIP is still required: Florida PIP explained.
FAQ
Will my premium drop by 12.6%?
Not necessarily. That's an average of filed rates across the biggest insurers. Your renewal can drop more, less, or still go up.
Did every insurer cut rates?
No. Many filed decreases, but not all, and not by the same amount.
Should I switch now or wait for my renewal?
You can switch any time. Your old insurer refunds unused premium, minus any cancellation fee in its policy, and David lines up the start date so there's no gap.
Do I need to apply for an excess-profits refund?
Refunds ordered under the excess-profits law are paid by the insurer to eligible policyholders. Watch for a notice from your insurer.
Is PIP going away in 2026?
No. It's still required on every registered car in Florida.
Your policy’s wording decides what’s covered. David can walk you through yours.